Whipsaw It Good
Dave Weigel is now in the employ of Slate, owned by the Washington Post, following his abruptly abbreviated tenure at — well, at the Washington Post, but let’s not get into that.
Instead, let’s take up his Wednesday column subheaded “African-American conservatives explain that the only racists are those who worry about race-based prejudice.” And let’s ignore the substance of the column, in order to focus on the complaint of commenter “Sissy Willis,” who calls Weigel out for using “code” language:
“Chorus line of black conservatives” = minstrel show
“tan suit/black shirt” = not authentically black/supporter of fascism
“reverse racism grievance industry” = anti-racism, anti-reverse-racism, all black people are alike
“whipsawed by conservative media” = punished by the overseer, e.g. Simon Legree
“bumper crop of black conservative stars” = sharecroppers
“professional black conservative” = paid puppet or Uncle Tom
And while we’re ignoring things — because hey, life is short — let’s dwell on Alleged Codeword #4: “whipsawed”.
Quite honestly — and we do pay attention — that’s a new one to us.
We don’t have our beloved American Heritage handy, but Merriam-Webster dates the verb to 1842:
to beset or victimize in two opposite ways at once, by a two-phase operation, or by the collusive action of two opponents (“wage earners were whipsawed by inflation and high taxes”)
Okay, that’s pretty much our understanding. You have an object that morphs into a colorful verb. Language is fun!
But Simon Legree?
We’re quite capable of missing something, but a Google search of “whipsaw legree” shoots a major blank. Which, while extremely unusual for a Google search, is not definitive.
So: Help us out. Is “whipsaw” coded racism? With documented historical or contemporary examples? Inquiring philosophical linguists want to know.
Smug David “White Boy” Weigel Angers Slate Readers [Riehl World View]
To answer my own question: It appears Sissy Willis is confusing “whipsaw” with “whip.”
Carry on.
@nojo: Whoops. Or is that Whipps?
Kagan made it in. Not exactly a TJ, but kind of a TJ.
@IanJ: I was thinking of TJing it myself, but couldn’t decide on the most absurd location.
@nojo: “couldn’t decide on the most absurd location.” A glimpse into the powerful, perverse, and intriguing mind of Nojo.
I always think of this when I think of “whipsaw.” And getting emotionally punched around — you feel like the log being sawed.
This ambiguously brown US citizen has no issue with the word. And FSM knows I can see racism around every fucking corner if I care to actually see it. But if I allow myself to, it just pisses me off.
@IanJ:
i may have to change my avatar in celebration.
Original Andrew: your gift to me of Ruthie flipping double birds is one of my favorite gifts of all time. got one with Elena?
gay marriage is on the horizon, i see it! and 6 ovaries Supreme.
i’m so happy happy happy!!! and Al, you’re good enough, you’re smart enough, and doggone it, i love you!
FLYINGCHAINSAW • Harris-Kelly ’24 PERFECTION! Bumper Sticker: HARRIS GIVES GOOD GURNEY!
NOJO • Harris-Kelly ’24 I know, getting ahead of the game here — and Gabby has the only vote — but let’s go down…
FLYINGCHAINSAW • Campaign 2024 Update 2024 General Election = White Power Vs. White Genocide The MAGAs will soon be opening fire on…
NOJO • Campaign 2024 Update Whatever table it was, just remember you didn’t have a seat at it.
NOJO • A Nation of Immigrants @nojo: Okay, here’s a thought: They broke it, they bought it.
FLYINGCHAINSAW • A Nation of Immigrants https://gettr.com/post/p38v9kc47ae
NOJO • A Nation of Immigrants @nojo: No original thoughts about the Democratic circus right now, for example, other than christ,…
NOJO • A Nation of Immigrants @Burr Deming: I may be back more often if he’s back. Right now anything I might say is just…
¡ANDREW! • A Nation of Immigrants Start the deportations by sending terrorists and fascist traitors E-loon Mush, Peter Thief, and all…
BURR DEMING • A Nation of Immigrants An accurate representation of how today's Republicans see a Nation of Immigrants. Welcome back,…