And Here’s To You, Justice Stevens…
Justice John Paul Stevens, king of the cranky-pants dissents, today writes a concurrence in Graham v. Florida for the sole purpose of bitch-slapping Justice Clarence Thomas. The ladies of SCOTUS joined him in the pile-on.
In his dissenting opinion, JUSTICE THOMAS argues that today’s holding is not entirely consistent with the controlling opinions in [string cite]. Post, at 7-9. Given that “evolving standards of decency” have played a central role in our Eighth Amendment jurisprudence for at least a century, [1910 case cite], this argument suggests the dissenting opinions in those cases more accurately describe the law today than does JUSTICE THOMAS’ rigid interpretation of the Amendment.
Society changes. Knowledge accumulates. We learn, sometimes, from our mistakes. Punishments that did not seem cruel and unusual at one time may, in the light of reason and experience, be found cruel and unusual at a later time; unless we are to abandon the moral commitment embodied in the Eighth Amendment, proportionality review must never become effectively obsolete, post at 8-9 and n.2.
While JUSTICE THOMAS would apparently not rule out a death sentence for a $50 theft by a 7-year-old, see post, at 4, 10, n.3, the Court wisely rejects his static approach to the law. Standards of decency have evolved since 1980. They will never stop doing so.
Damn, I’m going to miss that guy.
Awesomeness personified.
@Mistress Cynica: Did you see Toobin’s terrific profile of Stevens in the New Yorker a couple months ago? Great read. Fascinating and awesome guy, by all accounts of the people I know who worked for or near him.
You can excuse the Cubs fandom. A guy has to root for his home team, come what may.
@SanFranLefty: Hadn’t seen it. Thanks for the link.
They don’t make ’em like that anymore.
@Dodgerblue: I guess you’ve been reminding yourself that lately, eh Dodger?
@Dodgerblue:
that reminds me of this:
if a woman has to choose between catching a fly ball and saving an infants life, she will choose saving the infants life without even considering if there are men on base.
fare thee well Justice Stevens
My favorite judicial bitch slap since the Iowa Supreme Court gay marriage decision.
I will be next to Wrigley tonight, watching the Blackhawks game and imbibing and trying to avoid drunken Cubs fans.
@homofascist: Good luck with that.
@SanFranLefty: That Ford quote — “For I am prepared to allow history’s judgment of my term in office to rest (if necessary, exclusively) on my nomination thirty years ago of John Paul Stevens to the U.S. Supreme Court” — is fascinating. Thanks for the link.
NOJO • An Earworm for Elon @¡Andrew!: 2022 is now the ocean’s hottest year in the recorded history. Stored heat is building…
MANCHUCANDIDATE • An Earworm for Elon Another rich motherfucker can't accept losing. Bolo pulls a Trump, unleashes a wave of hopeless…
MANCHUCANDIDATE • An Earworm for Elon The stupidest part was watching various MSM talking heads DEMAND that the Dems save the GOPers from…
¡ANDREW! • An Earworm for Elon Lying media: And now back to declaring FLAWLESS VICTORY and demanding RED WAVE.
NOJO • An Earworm for Elon Looks like 15 is it, after what may be the weirdest adjournment vote in history, if history tracked…
¡ANDREW! • An Earworm for Elon These antics are delaying serious Republinazi bizniss, like:1. Ginning up fake investigations into…
NOJO • An Earworm for Elon Ten Speaker ballots. Free coffee!
¡ANDREW! • An Earworm for Elon @nojo: The ongoing climate disaster is just too great a problem over a century in the making for us…
NOJO • An Earworm for Elon @nojo: Also takes just ten Republicans to just sit out a vote and lower the majority threshold.…
NOJO • An Earworm for Elon @¡Andrew!: No specifics, but in general, I don’t see why this doesn’t go into next week. No…